What is Eating Disorders

An eating disorder is a compulsion in which the main problem is a person eats in a way which disturbs their physical health. The eating may be too excessive (compulsive over-eating...

Join Now

Free, anonymous support from people just like you.

Spread the Word!
Get a DS flyer to post
DS Store is Open
DS t-shirts and more
Discussion:
Hypocrite. (Advice needed on sister.)
Watch this 
View More Posts
WEIGHT AND TRIGGERS MENTIONED.

So, I'm not sure what to do.

I am 21, and have had an ED virtually all my life. My sister is 19 going on 20 in January. When I was 14 and really starting to "visibly" suffer, my sister was triggered by me (and some book she read, so she says- bah) at age 12. She suffered disordered eating for about a year, though was able to put it behind her as she became involved instead with drinking.

Now, the drinking and smoking and partying is behind her, and she an AMAZING musician: http://www.myspace.com/rickyberger

However, I think she has been really having problems dealing with my ED since I've been going to family counselling with her and she stays at my apartment with my husband and me sometimes when she comes down from northern CA where she lives now. She has been talking a lot about weight these days, mostly about how she is fat and needs to lose weight because she is in the public eye with her music. She is FAR from fat, folks- 5'7.5" and something like 130 pounds. She wears a size 2/4, and sometimes even a Gap size 0 (which she whines has gotten too tight for her- actually, they just make her butt look good, if I may say so). Like I told her, she is on the low side of the BMI scale, and is far from being overweight or even chubby. She eats pretty moderately, not much snacking unless she really is just relaxing- most of the time she is GO GO GO with her music and doesn't have time to stop. Her choices while eating out are moderate, and she chooses well. She is a nutritionist's dream.

However, she assures me that she needs to go on her old "cereal diet" where she would only eat cereal to lose weight (bah!)...I flipped out at that. She keeps saying she has the shoulders of a line-backer and flubby arms, and that she has a gut. NOT TRUE. She is also extremely selfconscious about the fact that she has a little extra hair on her...which to me is no big deal, but it is to her since people see her a lot in her typical 40's garb gettup. She has said that she needs to be skinny and that's the only way she looks good for her audience.

What can I do to convince her otherwise? Right now, she's having pizza on the couch, but I don't want her to slip. Today at lunch at Chili's she had a low-calorie chicken sandwich with a few fries...and I literally knew she was going to try to purge in the bathroom. She looked REALLY guilty when I followed her in (mostly cos I had to pee, but also because I was worried). All I want to do is boost her self-esteem, but how can I do that if I can't practise what I preach?
Posted on 10/04/07, 11:10 pm
RATE THIS POST:
Inspirational
Moving
Helpful
Creative
7 Replies Add Your Reply
Reminder: This is a support group for Eating Disorders. We trust you will do your best to remain positive and helpful. For more information, see our rules of the road.

You may also create your own Member Groups where you can moderate the discussion.
Comment:
Email me when others reply to this topic help
View More Posts
Reply #1 - 10/04/07  11:30pm
" this is a really challenging dilema....hmm... i wish i was more help...but as you know people will only accept help if they want it. i would write her a letter saying that you are always willing to lend a non-judgemental ear if she wants to talk. take care! "
RATE THIS REPLY:
Inspirational
Moving
Helpful
Creative
View More Posts
Reply #2 - 10/04/07  11:35pm
" I think in a way you are practicing what you preach. You are suffering and to let her in on your personal pain might allow her to open up if she is having bulimic tendencies. She may not feel so alone with her secrets, especially if you come from a place of love and compassion. "
RATE THIS REPLY:
Inspirational
Moving
Helpful
Creative
View More Posts
Reply #3 - 10/04/07  11:43pm
" Thanks guys. Your advice really counts. :) "
RATE THIS REPLY:
Inspirational
Moving
Helpful
Creative
View More Posts
Reply #4 - 10/05/07  6:05pm
" Give her a big hug and tell her that you love her and that you worry about her.
Then give her every ugly detail how ED destroys your life and how she will lose her joy and ability to be a great musician. Good luck. "
RATE THIS REPLY:
Inspirational
Moving
Helpful
Creative
View More Posts
Reply #5 - 10/05/07  6:17pm
" Wow and hug...you sound upset (of course) In my opinion....nothing you can do. She knows your story, life and whart you have gone threw and still are. Maybe this is a way she feels she can get even closer to you? Also as a singer song writer myself, there is many pressures put on you if you do not have your power positive barriers up. Focus on you and your love for your sister. Put yourself in her position what advise would you have taken? Maybe this is one of those times where passivity and venting on line / journalling etc is another option as well as confrontation?
Dunno
*hugs*
Sherose "
RATE THIS REPLY:
Inspirational
Moving
Helpful
Creative
View More Posts
Reply #6 - 10/05/07  8:22pm
" This makes me sad...because if she keeps on purging, she's going to lose her voice. If she truly wants to do something for the music and the fans, she needs to protect those precious vocal chords. (I know that's hard to see when you're the one standing up there under the lights.)


I think you need you need to be really honest, really calm, really supportive, let her know you know how it goes, and then let her go her own way until she's ready for help.

A large part of this is her own struggle, but some of this is going to be tied up in how she watched you struggle. I think you can understand her better than anyone right now, but maybe you can't be the one who can BE there. Maybe you can help her find that person.

Wishing you much love. "
RATE THIS REPLY:
Inspirational
Moving
Helpful
Creative
View More Posts
Reply #7 - 10/05/07  8:36pm
" I guess I should have made it more clear that she's not purging, as far as I know. I've never even really suspected it- I was only nervous of it. "
RATE THIS REPLY:
Inspirational
Moving
Helpful
Creative

You might also like ...

not diagnosed, but...

By drumline 1 Reply

I'm not exactly sure at what point it's called an eating disorder, but I binge. A lot. I eat very often, and most of …

so upset

By rowyn 10 Replies

just me venting, may trigger i've gained SIX pounds on a week, mostly in the past 2 days :'( i know it's wrong …

My Story - Need Help.

By mysilentshame 5 Replies

I am new here and I thought I would start by sharing my story. I have been struggling with bulimia since I was …

Content on DailyStrength.org is for informational purposes only. We do not provide any medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. More info
Copyright 2008 DailyStrength, Inc. All rights reserved. Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | Report Abuse